South Philly Pizza Menu (2025 Update)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to South Philly Pizza, your go-to spot in New Philadelphia, Ohio, for an unforgettable pizza experience. Nestled at 225 Commercial Ave SE, this local gem is celebrated for its mouthwatering menu that highlights authentic flavors and fresh ingredients.

The standout feature? The specialty pizzas, including Rusty’s Special and Pizza Bianco, that promise a crunchy crust paired with a delectably sweet sauce. Customers rave about the rich, melty cheeses and flavorful toppings, making each pizza an indulgence.

  • Salads: Start off with a classic AntiPasta for just $6.
  • Subs: Enjoy options like Buffalo Chicken and Grilled Chicken, all priced around $7.50.

Reviews from satisfied diners echo the sentiment: hot, fresh, and flavorful every time. Whether you're picking up dinner after work or enjoying a night out, South Philly Pizza ensures a satisfying meal that keeps you coming back for more.

Salads Subs Specialty Pizzas Chicken Pizzas Others

Salads

Anti-Pasta
US$6.00

Grilled Chicken

Hot Italian
US$7.50

Ham & Cheese
US$7.00

Meatball
US$7.50

Pizza
US$7.00

Chicken Bacon Ranch
US$7.50

Bbq Chicken
US$7.50

Grilled Chicken
US$7.50

Buffalo Chicken
US$7.50

Buffalo Chicken Ranch
US$7.50

Subs

Specialty Pizzas

Pizza Bianco

Rusty's Special

Meat Lovers

Veggie

Bbq Chicken

Buffalo Chicken

Buffalo Chicken Ranch

Chicken Bacon Ranch

White Chicken

Chicken Pizzas

Others

Pepsi Products
US$2.00

Garlic Bread With Cheese
US$4.50